The Toronto Blue Jays suffered a brutal sequence of events during Sunday’s matchup against the Pittsburgh Pirates, losing two of their most important players in the same inning. Pitcher Dylan Cease and first baseman Vladimir Guerrero Jr. both exited the game during the fifth inning, creating another injury concern for a team that has already been heavily impacted by health issues throughout the MLB season.

While initial reports suggest neither injury appears severe, the sight of two All-Star-caliber players leaving in the middle of a game was the last thing Toronto needed.

MORE: Former MLB World Series champion retires immediately, then changes his mind one day later

Fifth Inning Turns Into a Nightmare for Toronto

The Blue Jays difficult afternoon began in the top half of the fifth inning. Cease was forced to leave the game after appearing to suffer a leg injury. Shortly after his departure, Toronto announced that the right-hander exited due to left hamstring discomfort. Things only got worse in the bottom half of the inning.

Guerrero was struck by a sinker from Mitch Keller directly on the elbow. The impact immediately raised concern as Guerrero was removed from the game and replaced. Fortunately for Toronto, early testing delivered some positive news. The team later announced Guerrero had suffered a right elbow contusion, and X-rays came back negative for a fracture.

Toronto’s Injury Problems Continue to Grow

Even if Cease and Guerrero avoid lengthy absences, the injuries add to what has already become a difficult season from a health standpoint. The Blue Jays have been among the league’s most injury-riddled teams throughout the year. Currently on the injured list are catcher Alejandro Kirk, outfielder Nathan Lukes, and versatile player Addison Barger.

Toronto has also already lost key contributors for the season. Outfielder Anthony Santander is sidelined after undergoing shoulder surgery, while pitchers Jose Berrios, Bowden Francis, and Cody Ponce are all done for the year. In addition, Shane Bieber has yet to make his season debut, while veteran Max Scherzer also remains unavailable.

Cease’s Durability Has Been One of His Greatest Strengths

One of the most concerning aspects of Cease’s injury is how unusual it is to see him sidelined at all. Since making his major league debut with the White Sox in 2019, Cease has built a reputation as one of baseball’s most durable starting pitchers.

Outside of a brief COVID-related injured list stint in 2021, he has avoided major injury issues throughout his career. Since the shortened 2020 season, Cease has made at least 32 starts every year, consistently taking the ball and giving his team dependable innings.

Because of that track record, any injury involving the right-hander naturally attracts additional attention.

Guerrero Has Rarely Missed Time

Guerrero’s injury history is equally impressive. Across eight major league seasons, the Blue Jays star has never landed on the injured list. Durability has been a major part of his value to Toronto, as he has appeared in at least 155 games and surpassed 675 plate appearances in each of the last five seasons.

Players with that type of availability are difficult to replace. Although the initial diagnosis appears encouraging, Toronto will undoubtedly proceed cautiously with one of the most important bats in its lineup.

Blue Jays Hoping for Good News

The immediate outlook appears better than the worst-case scenarios many feared when both players exited Sunday afternoon. Negative X-rays for Guerrero provide relief, and hamstring discomfort does not necessarily indicate a serious issue for Cease.

Still, for a team already dealing with a seemingly endless list of injuries, even short absences would create another challenge. The Blue Jays have already spent much of the season trying to overcome health setbacks. Losing two All-Star players in the same inning served as another reminder of just how quickly things can change during a long baseball season.

— Enjoy free coverage of the top news & trending stories on The Big Lead —

The Blue Jays go for a three-game sweep Sunday in Toronto, while the Pirates try to stop a two-game skid and salvage the finale at Rogers Centre.

MORE:5 MLB players who should be traded during the 2026 season

How to Watch Pirates vs Blue Jays

• Date: Sunday, May 24, 2026
• Time: 12:15 PM ET
• Channel: Peacock
• Stream: Peacock (watch now)

Toronto has taken the first two games of the series, winning 6-2 on Friday and 5-2 on Saturday, and enters Sunday at 25-27 with four straight wins. The Blue Jays will start Dylan Cease, who has been excellent so far at 3-2 with a 2.98 ERA and 84 strikeouts over 57.1 innings, giving Toronto a strong chance to finish off the sweep.

– Live Stream Pirates vs Blue Jays with Peacock –

Pittsburgh comes in at 26-26 after dropping back-to-back games in Toronto, but the Pirates still have a solid run differential and a competitive pitching staff. Mitch Keller gets the ball for Pittsburgh with a 4-2 record, 3.86 ERA and 1.06 WHIP, while the offense leans on Oneil Cruz, who leads the club with 33 RBIs, and Brandon Lowe, who has 13 home runs.

This is a great MLB matchup that you will not want to miss; make sure to tune in and catch all the action.

Live stream Pirates vs Blue Jays on Peacock: Start your subscription now!

With Peacock, you can watch live television without cable on your phone, TV, or tablet. They carry a wide array of sports and entertainment channels, including every Sunday Night Baseball game throughout the MLB season.

Regional restrictions may apply. If you purchase a product or register for an account through one of the links on our site, we may receive compensation.

— Enjoy free coverage of the top news & trending stories on The Big Lead —