Barry Bonds nearly joined Yankees until this one thing made him change his mind

Yahoo! Sports - News, Scores, Standings, Rumors, Fantasy Games

26 March 2026 at 18:42

Barry Bonds came close to becoming a Yankee, and the story behind why it didn’t happen is wild. The baseball legend opened up during Opening Night on Netflix, sharing details about his 1992 free agency and how a phone call from George Steinbrenner ended any chance of him suiting up in pinstripes.

Bonds was appearing on the broadcast for the New York Yankees–San Francisco Giants matchup when he finally talked about how real those negotiations were. After back-to-back MVP seasons with the Pittsburgh Pirates, Bonds was the biggest name on the market.

MORE: Cincinnati Reds mark Opening Day on showpiece gift from franchise legend

The Yankees wanted him, and Steinbrenner was ready to make him the highest-paid player in MLB at the time. But then came the catch.

“George isn’t here anymore, so I can tell the truth, right?” Bonds said. “I would’ve been the Yankees, but Steinbrenner got on the phone, and they called us, and they told me, ‘Barry, we’re gonna give you the money, highest paid player at that time. But you have to sign the contract by 2:00 this afternoon,’ and I said, ‘Excuse me?’ and I just hung the phone up.”

That ultimatum did not sit right with Bonds. The tight deadline felt more like pressure than a negotiation, and he was not about to rush into a decision that big. His agent, Dennis Gilbert, called him right after to make sure he understood what he’d just walked away from.

Bonds did not care. He was not interested in being forced into anything, no matter how much money was on the table.

“By the time I walked down the street to go get lunch. I said, ‘Let me just think about this.’ Then the Giants called me, and I said, ‘I’m going home,'” Barry added.

Barry Bonds watches warmups for the Minnesota Timberwolves and Golden State Warriors before the second round for the 2025 NBA Playoffs. Mandatory Credit: David Gonzales-Imagn Images

MORE: AL champs George Springer, Ernie Clement sit in wrong seats at Maple Leafs game

So instead of heading to New York, Bonds went back to the Bay Area. That choice defined his career. He spent 15 seasons with the San Francisco Giants, won four more MVP awards, and broke the all-time home run record.

But it is tough not to think about what could have been if he’d signed that afternoon. Bonds in Yankee Stadium with that short porch in right field is a fun what-if that’ll never stop floating around.