Reading view

Reviews of Netflix’s Home Run Derby telecast are one-sided

Netflix’s maiden Home Run Derby telecast came with plenty of hype. The field of participants included stars both familiar (Bryce Harper, Kyle Schwarber) and new (Junior Caminero, Munetaka Murakami), from the east (Ben Rice, Willson Contreras ) and midwest (Jac Caglianone, Jordan Walker).

In the end, the July 13 exhibition at Citizens Bank Park in Philadelphia was remarkable not for who was or wasn’t on the field, but how the streaming giant mastered the details.

Judging by the early reviews of the event, mastery remains out of reach.

MORE: Phillies’ Bryce Harper breaks Home Run Derby announcement on Instagram

Some online commentators criticized Netflix’s maximalist camera cuts, which seemed bound by law not to hold a single shot for more than 2 seconds at a time.

Despite the many angles available to the director, a number of viewers noted that the act of the bat hitting the ball was often ignored.

MORE: Phillies announce death of former All-Star closer

“If a camera angle doesn’t show me the bat coming off the ball, I don’t want to see that angle,” Jason Foster of MLB.com wrote on Twitter/X.

“Netflix knows the worst part of the Derby is watching that moment of impact where the bat meets the ball,” Pirates beat writer Alex Stumpf wrote on Twitter/X. “The people yearn for close ups of faces and then cuts to balls mid-flight.”

Some criticized the new format, which eliminated the countdown timer for the first time in 11 years.

Others criticized the lack of numbers on the screen. Besides each player’s remaining number of swings and the distance (in feet) of each home run, the cameras and commentators were left to tell the story.

MORE: All-Star pitcher lashes out at team’s radio station, deletes social media account

Others criticized Netflix’s choice of entertainment personalities — Jimmy Tatro, Will Ferrell and Luke Wilson — who warmed up the broadcast.

“Oh my God, the three guys doing supposed comedic commentary on the Home Run Derby player intros are the least funny people to be given such a national stage, without question,” longtime Atlanta Braves beat writer David O’Brien wrote on Twitter/X. “They. Are. Brutal. Who wrote these godawful lines for them? Embarrassing, Netflix. Utterly embarrassing.”

Considering many fans of the Home Run Derby likely subscribed to Netflix just to watch the one event, it was an underwhelming debut.

15 best baseball announcers of all time

Baseball’s soundtrack of summer has always depended on the voices in the booth as much as the players on the field. The right call can turn a routine summer night into a memory that lives in a fan base forever.

As the 2026 MLB season reaches the unofficial halfway mark with this week’s All-Star Game and turns toward the stretch run, it’s a good time to reflect on the game’s most memorable voices.

MORE: Ranking the 13 most memorable moments in MLB All-Star Game history

This list of the 15 best baseball announcers of all time leans on impact, longevity, big moments and, just as important, how they sounded sitting in the car or on the couch in July when nothing much was happening.

These are the voices that defined how the sport sounds.

15. Phil Rizzuto

A Hall of Fame player with the New York Yankees, Phil Rizzuto moved right from the playing field to the broadcast booth. His idiosyncratic, conversational style played well in the Big Apple for 40 years before he retired in 1996.

Who can forget Rizzuto’s signature phrase, “Holy cow!” And, yes, that’s him providing the play-by-play of a young man “rounding the bases” in the Meat Loaf song “Paradise by the Dashboard Lights.”

14. Bob Costas

Bob Costas famously got his start in broadcasting with the ABA’s St. Louis Spirits when he was just 22 years old. But baseball was his first love, and it showed. It wasn’t long before Costas got the “Game of the Week” job alongside Tony Kubek.

Costas’ encyclopedic knowledge of the game and humor formed a perfect mix for baseball broadcasts on television. He went on to broadcast several World Series and league championship series, both as a play-by-play man and pregame host.

The winner of 29 Emmy awards for his work in sports, news and entertainment, Costas still pops up on MLB Network as the host of documentaries.

13. Jerry Coleman

Jerry Coleman’s path to the booth ran through the field and military service, and he brought that perspective to decades of San Diego Padres broadcasts. He was known for good-natured malapropisms and slightly scrambled calls that fans came to love, as well as for a catchphrase that lived on in San Diego sports culture.

Coleman’s long-running “Oh, Doctor!” exclamation after big plays helped define Padres baseball on radio for multiple generations of fans in Southern California.

Behind the quirks, Coleman knew the game and never faked his way through a sequence. His style is a reminder that perfection is not the point; connection is.

12. Harry Kalas

Harry Kalas’ deep, rolling baritone became inseparable from the Philadelphia Phillies. His “Outta here!” home run call filled summers in the Delaware Valley, and his work on NFL Films projects gave him a second life as a legendary narrator in another sport.

For Phillies fans, Kalas provided constancy through lean years and eventual championships, including the 2008 World Series run that gave him a long overdue title call. His voice gave even routine plays a sense of weight without ever feeling heavy-handed.

11. Joe Buck

Few modern broadcasters inspire stronger opinions than Joe Buck, which usually means a guy has been on a lot of important calls. He became the primary national TV voice of the postseason at a relatively young age and stayed in that seat for two decades, layering his own style on top of the expectations that came with being Jack Buck’s son.

Joe Buck brought a measured, sometimes dry delivery that let big October moments speak for themselves. He was on the call for iconic plays such as the Red Sox breaking their title drought in 2004 and the Cardinals’ wild comeback in Game 6 of the 2011 World Series. Whether fans loved him or complained about him, his voice is attached to a long list of plays everyone remembers.

10. Curt Gowdy

Curt Gowdy spent years as the national voice for big events across multiple sports, and baseball was one of the primary beneficiaries. He called World Series, All-Star Games and classic postseason matchups in an era when there might be only one national telecast for a given game, which meant his calls effectively became the official record.

Gowdy’s style was straightforward and uncluttered, the sound of someone who trusted that the game would deliver the drama on its own. That approach has aged well. Listening back, there is no forced catchphrase or manufactured intensity, just a professional voice giving context to important baseball moments.

9. Bob Uecker

Bob Uecker was probably as famous for joking about his own playing career as he was for anything that happened on the field, and that self-deprecation powered decades of entertaining Milwaukee Brewers broadcasts. He also became a pop culture figure through late-night TV appearances and the “Major League” movies, but in Wisconsin he was the voice that guided fans through 162 games.

Uecker mixed dry humor with sharp play-by-play instincts, never missing the action even when he was clearly having fun with the audience. He kept Brewers baseball light during long rebuilds and heightened the joy when the team finally started stacking playoff berths again. The fact that locals simply call him “Ueck” says everything about how personal that connection has become.

8. Jon Miller

Jon Miller has one of the most recognizable voices in baseball and a delivery that can shift from lyrical to deadpan in a heartbeat. He spent years as the national Sunday night voice and has been a fixture on San Francisco Giants broadcasts, calling everything from Barry Bonds’ home run chase to multiple World Series runs.

Miller’s strength is precision. His descriptions are vivid but never crowded, and he brings an international flair with his playful use of accents and languages when appropriate. He made national broadcasts feel like big events without losing the rhythm of a regular baseball game.

7. Joe Garagiola

Joe Garagiola brought a former player’s insight and a comedian’s timing to national baseball broadcasts. A catcher turned broadcaster, he became a familiar voice on the Game of the Week and multiple World Series, helping casual fans understand what was happening without talking down to them.

Garagiola’s strength was his ability to weave in anecdotes that actually explained things, rather than simply filling air time. He could make viewers laugh at a mound conference or an error while still outlining the strategy behind the next pitch. His blend of accessibility and credibility set a template for the color role on national baseball coverage.

6. Ernie Harwell

In Detroit, Ernie Harwell was more than an announcer. He was a companion for summer after summer, with a welcoming tone and gentle sense of humor that made Tigers games feel like family gatherings. Harwell had a knack for turning mundane elements of a game into ritual, from his “stood there like the house by the side of the road” strikeout line to noting fans catching foul balls “from Kalamazoo” or “from Windsor.”

He called games for more than four decades in Detroit, and his consistency and warmth built a trust few broadcasters ever achieve. Harwell made listeners feel like they were exactly where they were supposed to be, and that is a rare gift in a long season.

5. Jack Buck

Jack Buck’s voice is stitched into the fabric of both St. Louis Cardinals history and national baseball memory. His “Go crazy, folks! Go crazy!” reaction to Ozzie Smith’s 1985 NLCS home run remains one of the sport’s most replayed calls, and his work on national radio placed him in people’s living rooms for multiple generations of postseason moments.

Buck combined Midwest calm with a knack for capturing the tone of a game in a simple phrase. He never tried to be the show, but when the moment called for a strong line, he invariably had one ready. That economy of words is a big reason he is still held up as a model for baseball play-by-play.

4. Harry Caray

Harry Caray turned the broadcast booth into a neighborhood bar, first in St. Louis and then in Chicago, where he became synonymous with Wrigley Field and the Cubs. His slurred vowels, mispronunciations and genuine awe for what he was seeing made him feel more like a fan with a microphone than a polished broadcaster. That was exactly the point.

Caray’s energy, including his signature “Holy cow!” and his willingness to lead the crowd in “Take Me Out to the Ball Game,” turned ordinary regular season games into events. He was not perfect on details and barely pretended to be neutral, but he captured the emotional side of baseball fandom in a way that still resonates in Chicago lore.

3. Mel Allen

For a huge chunk of the 20th century, Mel Allen was the voice of the New York Yankees and, by extension, the voice of winning. His “How about that!” catchphrase could be heard on radio, television and highlight packages at a time when the Yankees were stacking championships and stars. Allen had an enthusiastic but controlled style that fit both the local broadcast and the emerging national appetite for baseball highlights.

He later became the host and narrator of “This Week in Baseball,” where his smooth delivery and sense of pacing introduced fans around the country to plays they never would have otherwise seen. Allen’s work helped bridge the gap between local radio calls and the national TV era that followed.

2. Red Barber

Red Barber helped invent the language of baseball on radio. Long before every market had its own signature voice, Barber was painting pictures for Dodgers, Reds and Yankees fans with a southern cadence and a string of homespun phrases. He popularized turns of phrase that still pop up in broadcasts, from “sitting in the catbird seat” to describing a close game as “tighter than a new pair of shoes.”

Barber’s work in Brooklyn set the table for Scully, and his influence on how play-by-play is described can be heard throughout the generations that followed. He did not just call the action; he framed games as narratives long before that became standard practice.

1. Vin Scully

Vin Scully is the standard every baseball broadcaster gets measured against. From Brooklyn to Los Angeles, from Jackie Robinson to Clayton Kershaw, he spent 67 seasons calling Dodgers games and still somehow sounded curious and sharp into his final year behind the mic. Scully mastered the balance between play-by-play and storytelling, dropping in anecdotes that felt like they belonged to the moment instead of distracting from it.

He called some of the most famous plays in baseball history, including Kirk Gibson’s hobbling home run in the 1988 World Series and Hank Aaron’s 715th home run. What separates Scully is how often he understood that silence could be more powerful than any line he might write. He laid out after big moments and let ballparks speak for themselves, trusting that fans at home did not need their hands held.

MLB insider reveals team most likely to go get Tarik Skubal at trade deadline

The Detroit Tigers have played much better baseball recently to climb back into the American League playoff chase. It will still take some doing for the team to overcome a dreadful start and get into the postseason. Not many people believe that the reigning American League Cy Young winner will be around to see if the Tigers can accomplish that because is is clearly the most coveted commodity for other teams as the MLB trade deadline nears. Even though Skubal has made it clear that he wants to stick around the Motor City for at least a little longer.

We’ll soon have resolution on his immediate future. And whichever franchise gets to send him out to the mound every five days will be thrilled. He’s a fan favorite in Detroit despite all the drama of the last several months and if he got a new home, those fans would go berserk.

Skubal at the trade deadline

ESPN’s baseball insider Jeff Passan added his insight into the biggest trade deadline character and question on Monday’s “Get Up”, along the way revealing which team is most likely to acquire his services.

“If there’s a team that’s gonna go get Tarik SKubal, … it is the Los Angeles Dodgers,” Passan said.

Such a development would not sit well with 29 other fanbases. The Dodgers have the best record in baseball at 61-36 and are seeking their third straight World Series. Throw a dart at their roster and it’s likely to hit an All-Star.

“They can pretty much do what they want at this point,” Passan said before pointing out that the team has been active and not so active during previous trade deadlines during their dynastic run.

Skubal’s future

Look, I’m a Tigers fan and believe Skubal is going to stay in Detroit. But if he does land with the Dodgers, crushing my team’s hopes and only making Los Angeles more of a wagon, then so be it. The Dodgers can do pretty much anything they want at this point and still win a World Series. It’s downright scary to think of how many of those they could string together if they got Skubal’s services for years to come.

The reason there’s no reason to let what the Dodgers do get under your skin is because it’s so competent. It feels like an overwhelming majority of sports fans spend their lives decrying local ownership and all the boneheaded decisions that are made. We suffer because organizations can’t figure it out and never put a premium on winning. So why be made at the one who has perfected it?

Of course that’s easy for me to say now. Check back a few hours after Skubal to the Dodgers becomes a reality and you’ll likely find a broken man.

❌