Let me be clear: this is not a reported trade. But if Adley Rutschman ever becomes available, there’s one team that should be one of the first making the call. The San Diego Padres. Rutschman is still a valuable player. Through early June, he is hitting .258 with seven home runs and 30 RBIs for Baltimore. That is not a collapse. It is also not the superstar offensive profile many expected when he became one of MLB‘s most important young catchers.

MORE: MLB Power Rankings: 30 teams ranked worst to first on June 4th, 2026

Orioles Direction:

The bigger concern is the direction of the Orioles. Baltimore entered Thursday at 29-33 and fourth in the AL East. That does not mean the Orioles have to sell, but it does make every big-picture roster question more interesting. If Baltimore decides it needs a reset around its young core, Rutschman would be the kind of name that changes the entire deadline conversation.

They also have another excellent young catcher in Samuel Basallo, who is expected to be their catcher of the future. Bassalo’s presence is what makes Adley expendable.

Padres Make Sense

San Diego makes sense because the catcher remains a position worth watching.

The Padres opened the season with Freddy Fermin as the primary catcher and Luis Campusano as the backup. Their current depth chart lists Fermin, Rodolfo Durán, and Campusano, who is on the 10-day injured list. That is functional, but it is not the kind of setup that should stop a contender from chasing a major upgrade.

Rutschman would give San Diego something different. He is a switch-hitting catcher with star pedigree, postseason expectations, and enough offensive upside to change the bottom half of a lineup. He also would not be a rental, which matters for a Padres team that usually thinks bigger than short-term patchwork.

The hard part is obvious. Baltimore would not give him away, and San Diego would have to build a painful package. But from a fit standpoint, this one works.

Rutschman may not need saving. But if he ever needs a reset, San Diego is the team that makes the most sense.

— Enjoy free coverage of the top news & trending stories on The Big Lead —