The 2025-26 Premier League season is moving toward its final stretch, and there is still plenty left to decide before the last round of fixtures in May. The title race remains tight, and that matters because the Premier League Player of the Season award has often gone to a player from the eventual champions. Still, history has shown that the prize does not always follow the team that lifts the trophy. Individual form, consistency, and impact in key moments can all shape the final vote, even when the title picture is still unsettled.

This season has produced a strong group of contenders across the league. Arsenal’s defensive base has stood out, with Gabriel leading a back line that has kept the team in the race. Manchester City have leaned on the scoring power of Erling Haaland, while Antoine Semenyo has delivered a strong season across two clubs and shown he can influence a title chase. Declan Rice has remained one of Arsenal’s most reliable performers in midfield, combining control with end product. Bruno Fernandes has also been central to Manchester United’s season, producing elite numbers in goals, assists, and chance creation. With so many players making a clear case, the award is shaping up as one of the most open races in years.

MORE: Soccer superstar Lionel Messi draws crowd at F1 Miami Grand Prix

1. Bruno Fernandes, Manchester United

Bruno Fernandes has been the standout individual in the Premier League this season. He has delivered 18 assists so far, just two short of the league record, and has also scored eight goals. His numbers in chance creation and big chances created place him at the top of the division in key creative categories. That kind of output has kept Manchester United in contention during a season that began poorly.

What makes Fernandes a strong candidate is not just the raw statistics, but the way he influences every phase of attack. Michael Carrick’s arrival has given him more freedom, and he has used it well from a No. 10 role. He has drifted wide, dropped deep, and still found ways to create chances from different areas of the pitch. If he breaks the assist record, his case for Player of the Season becomes even stronger. Even without team success, his season has been too important to ignore.

2. Declan Rice, Arsenal

Declan Rice has been Arsenal’s most consistent performer this season. He has driven the team from midfield and has provided a steady blend of control, ball-winning, and forward support. His overall influence has been central to Arsenal’s title push. In a season with several strong attackers, Rice has stood out as one of the most complete players in the league.

His value goes beyond visible goal contributions. He has helped Arsenal stay balanced in big matches and has given the side a reliable base in the middle of the pitch. That consistency matters in a title race where small margins decide everything. Rice may not draw the same attention as a top scorer, but his all-round performances have been among the best in the Premier League. If Arsenal finish first, he will have a strong case to win the award.

3. Erling Haaland, Manchester City

Erling Haaland remains one of the strongest individual forces in the Premier League. He is currently leading the league in goals, and his scoring has kept Manchester City close to the title race. Even though this season has not matched all of his previous numbers, his output is still at an elite level. City would not be in the same position without his goals.

Haaland already has a Player of the Season award from 2022-23, and he has shown again why he belongs in the conversation every year. His finishing has been consistent, and his presence continues to shape the way opponents defend against City. If Manchester City win the title, he looks like their most likely winner. A third Golden Boot would only strengthen his claim further.

4. Antoine Semenyo, Manchester City

Antoine Semenyo has put together an excellent season across two clubs. He scored 10 goals for Bournemouth before moving to Manchester City in January, and he has remained a regular starter since arriving in Manchester. That kind of transition is not easy, but he has handled it well. He has brought energy, goals, and direct play to two different teams in one campaign.

Semenyo’s case is built on impact and consistency. He may not have the profile of Fernandes or Haaland, but his season has been valuable and productive. He has been able to contribute in different systems and has given Manchester City another strong attacking option. For a player who moved midseason and still kept delivering, that deserves attention. If City finish with the title, he could enter the conversation more seriously.

5. Gabriel, Arsenal

Gabriel has been the leader of Arsenal’s defense and one of the biggest reasons the team has stayed near the top. Arsenal’s back line has been the best in the league in goals conceded and clean sheets, and Gabriel has been central to that success. He has also added three goals and four assists, which is strong production for a center back. His work at both ends of the pitch has given Arsenal an edge in tight games.

MORE: Every NFL stadium’s new name for the FIFA World Cup

Conclusion

Set pieces have been a major part of his value this season. He has been a constant threat in the box and has helped turn dead-ball situations into real scoring chances. Defenders rarely win Player of the Season, but Gabriel has done enough to deserve a place on this list. His chances depend heavily on Arsenal winning the title, but his influence has been obvious throughout the season.

The Premier League race is still open, and that keeps the Player of the Season discussion alive. Bruno Fernandes has the strongest individual case, while Declan Rice, Erling Haaland, Antoine Semenyo, and Gabriel each bring a different kind of value. As the season ends, the award may reflect both team success and individual impact. The same debate will carry into a busy football summer and the build-up to the FIFA World Cup.