10 Major Talking Points from the Carabao Cup Fourth Round
The 2025-26 Carabao Cup fourth round had everything, chaos, controversy, and a few shocks that left fans talking long after the final whistle. As the dust settles on a wild set of fixtures played on October 29, Softfootball brings you the ten biggest stories that shaped this thrilling round.
1. Liverpool’s Crisis Deepens After Palace Humbling
It just keeps getting worse for Arne Slot. Liverpool’s 3-0 defeat to Crystal Palace at Anfield was their sixth loss in seven games, a nightmare stretch for a side once famed for intensity and resilience. Ismaïla Sarr ran riot, scoring twice, and exposing glaring defensive gaps. Slot blamed rotation, but fans weren’t having it. With Aston Vila next in the League and Real Madrid next in the Champions League, the pressure couldn’t be heavier.

2. Arsenal’s Youngsters Deliver Again
Despite making ten changes, Mikel Arteta’s decision to field 10 changes worked a treat as Arsenal calmly beat Brighton 2-0. Arsenal looked composed and purposeful. Eighteen-year-old Ethan Nwaneri broke through with a composed finish in the 57th minute, and Bukayo Saka added the second to seal the win. What stood out wasn’t just the result, but the confidence with which the youthful side played. Arteta called it a “special evening” and underlined how crucial integrating youth is when injuries pile up.
3. Manchester City Survive Swansea Scare Thanks to Late Cherki Goal
City’s rotated lineup nearly paid the price. Early on, Franco stunned Manchester City with a goal in minute 12. Doku equalized before half, but breaking down Swansea’s defense proved a slog However, Marmoush scored City’s second to give them the lead, before Cherki’s, stoppage time winner rescued a 3–1 victory. Guardiola himself admitted the experiment invited embarrassment but showed faith in his squad’s depth.

4. Chelsea Escape Wolves’ Fury in 4-3 Thriller Amid Delap Red Card Controversy
Chelsea looked dominant early. Andrey Santos, Tyrique George, and Estêvão Willian built a 3–0 half-time lead. But Wolves were not done. Arokodare pulled one back early in the second half, and David Moller Wolfe made it 3–2 in the 73rd, setting up a tense finish.
The red card to Liam Delap in the 86th, for a second yellow, added fuel to the fire. Minutes later Jamie Gittens volleyed in a brilliant fourth for Chelsea, only for Wolfe to lob the keeper in injury time and make it 4–3. The result was survival, but not without questions over discipline.
5. Newcastle Dominate Tottenham 2-0 at St James’ Park
Newcastle were in control throughout, dispatching Spurs 2–0. Fabian Schär opened the scoring in the 23rd minute, and Nick Woltemade added the second early in the second half. Spurs manager Thomas Frank was incensed by what he perceived as a refereeing lapse: he claimed Chris Kavanagh failed to allow Djed Spence time to retie his boot before the opener. Whether valid or not, the controversy only added spice to a commanding Magpies display.
6. Cardiff City Make History with Wrexham Victory
One of the most enchanting stories of the round: Cardiff City, a League One side, knocked out Wrexham 2–1 to reach the quarter-finals. Their journey has become the sentimental favourite of the tournament. Their next tie is hosting Chelsea, a clash that will be talked about for more than its result.
7. Brentford Edge Grimsby 5-0; Fulham Survive Wycombe Penalty Drama
Brentford made a statement. Their 5–0 thrashing of Grimsby displayed attacking breadth and ruthlessness. Fulham, meanwhile, were made to sweat. After drawing 1–1 with Wycombe, they edged through 5–4 on penalties. The stark contrast in methods, one emphatic, the other scrappy, will influence how both are viewed going forward and also tells a tale of how difficult the EFEL can become if taken with levity.
8. Refereeing Controversy Overshadows Newcastle’s Victory
The situation around Tottenham’s claimed injustice at St James’ overshadowed what was otherwise a solid Magpies performance. Frank’s vocal displeasure over Spence’s boot incident reminded everyone just how fine the line is in refereeing, especially in high-stakes cup ties. Decisions like this amplify pressure, raise questions about fairness, and linger long after the final whistle. Tottenham posted a video of the coach’s reaction in a post made via the team’s official X account.
Watch the video below:
Thomas Frank reflects on tonight’s display
— Tottenham Hotspur (@SpursOfficial) October 29, 2025pic.twitter.com/eiacFu0FHK
9. Rotation Strategies Divide Managers and Fans
This round exposed the double-edged sword of rotation. Some, like Arteta and Guardiola, got away with bold changes. Others, like Slot, paid a heavy price. When you bench key players at critical times, especially in cup ties — the margin for error vanishes. The fine balance between giving rest and maintaining competitiveness came sharply into focus.
10. Quarter-Final Draw Sets Up Dramatic Paths
The stage is now set for thrilling ties:
- Arsenal vs Crystal Palace — A London derby with storylines built in (Eberechi Eze returns to face his old club).
- Manchester City vs Brentford — A rematch of last season’s FA Cup final.
- Newcastle vs Fulham — Tested depth and ambition.
- Cardiff vs Chelsea — A fairytale run meets established power.
As legs are drawn for mid-December, the Carabao Cup quarter-finals promise drama, upsets, and renewed narratives.





 Barcelona’s talent Tommy Marques has trained with the first team today on his birthday.
 Barcelona’s talent Tommy Marques has trained with the first team today on his birthday.




 ‘HE’S THE GUY WHO CHANGED ME’
 ‘HE’S THE GUY WHO CHANGED ME’
 Full interview:
 Full interview: 


 
 








 Kovac on Waldemar Anton:
 Kovac on Waldemar Anton: 





 (@MrChelsealad02)
 (@MrChelsealad02)  Imagine spending almost half a billion pounds in the transfer window only to be playing with players nobody knows.
 Imagine spending almost half a billion pounds in the transfer window only to be playing with players nobody knows. 






 
 

 Arne Slot on team selection: “I haven't changed my mind after the game”.
 Arne Slot on team selection: “I haven't changed my mind after the game”.

 
 
 
 





 
  
 




 𝐅𝐔𝐋𝐋 𝐓𝐈𝐌𝐄
 𝐅𝐔𝐋𝐋 𝐓𝐈𝐌𝐄 











 
 



 
 





 
 


 
 



 "We’re hoping for a wonderful atmosphere out there and to have a really good night for the football club."
 "We’re hoping for a wonderful atmosphere out there and to have a really good night for the football club." 
 








 
  (@oflaelae)
 (@oflaelae) 
















 
  
 



 ‘IT’S ARSENAL’S TO LOSE’
 ‘IT’S ARSENAL’S TO LOSE’  Just 3 goals conceded
 Just 3 goals conceded 6 clean sheets in nine games
 6 clean sheets in nine games 









 
 
 (@realmadriden)
 (@realmadriden) 








 
 




 
 

 
 








 
 






 The schedule
 The schedule 
 Leão
 Leão






 
 
 Next Up: Brentford (H)
 Next Up: Brentford (H)


 
 





 
  
 


 
  
 
 
 









 
 
 
 
 
  (@afcbournemouth)
 (@afcbournemouth)  
 































 
 





 
 





 
 












 
 













 "This is far [bigger] than anything I dreamed about."
 "This is far [bigger] than anything I dreamed about." 
 








 Raphinha left today’s training session after good feelings yesterday to get the green light.
 Raphinha left today’s training session after good feelings yesterday to get the green light.